C.H. Dodd Get it on Kindle

C.H. Dodd › Realized eschatology

Realized eschatology: C.H. Dodd's view of the kingdom of God

Did Jesus expect the world to end soon, and was he wrong? In 1935 Dodd offered a bold answer: the kingdom Jesus announced was not waiting in the future. It had arrived.

In shortRealized eschatology is C.H. Dodd's view that when Jesus spoke of the kingdom of God, he meant something already present in his own ministry, not a coming catastrophe at the end of history. The "last things" had, in his phrase, been realized.

What the words mean

Eschatology comes from the Greek eschatos, "last". It is the part of theology that deals with the last things: the end of the age, judgement, resurrection and the final reign of God. Realized means made real, or brought about. Put together, the phrase claims that these last things are not only ahead of us: in some decisive sense, they have already happened.

The problem Dodd was answering

In the early twentieth century, Albert Schweitzer's The Quest of the Historical Jesus had shaken New Testament scholarship. Schweitzer argued that Jesus expected God to bring history to a dramatic close within his own generation. On that reading, sometimes called "consistent" or "thoroughgoing" eschatology, Jesus was a prophet of an imminent end that never came.

For many readers this was troubling. If the centre of Jesus' message was a prediction that failed, what was left? Dodd accepted that Jesus' language was eschatological, but he questioned whether Schweitzer had read it correctly.

Dodd's answer: the kingdom has come

Dodd pointed to sayings in which Jesus speaks of God's kingdom as already at work:

  • "If I cast out demons by the finger of God, then the kingdom of God has come upon you" Luke 11:20; Matthew 12:28
  • Jesus' opening proclamation that "the kingdom of God is at hand" Mark 1:15, which Dodd read as announcing its arrival, not merely its nearness.
  • Jesus' words that many prophets longed to see what his disciples were seeing Luke 10:23–24

For Dodd, the ministry, death and resurrection of Jesus were themselves the great event the prophets had looked for. God's reign had broken into history. The future-sounding language of judgement and glory expressed the meaning of that event, the eternal significance of what had happened in Jesus, more than a timetable of events still to come.

Reading the parables

Dodd developed the idea in The Parables of the Kingdom (1935). He argued that each parable had first been spoken into a specific moment, Jesus' own ministry, and was meant to provoke a decision there and then. Only later did the church reapply many of them to its own situation, especially its wait for Christ's return.

So a parable of a harvest, for example, announced that harvest time had come. Parables of crisis, such as the watchful servants, warned Jesus' hearers that the critical hour was upon them, before the church read them as warnings about a distant second coming.

Three views of the kingdom

Dodd's work sits between two other positions, and it helped produce the view most scholars hold today.

Consistent eschatologyRealized eschatologyInaugurated eschatology
Key figureAlbert SchweitzerC.H. DoddJoachim Jeremias, Oscar Cullmann, G.E. Ladd
The kingdom isEntirely future and imminentPresent in Jesus' ministryBegun in Jesus, completed in the future
Summary"Not yet, but very soon""Already""Already and not yet"
Main weaknessMakes Jesus' central message a failed predictionPlays down sayings about a future comingCritics say it can blur the tension rather than resolve it

John's Gospel: realized eschatology at its clearest

Dodd found the fullest expression of this outlook in the Gospel of John. There, eternal life is something believers have now, judgement is already taking place as people respond to Jesus, and the coming of the Spirit fulfils much of what other writers expected at the end. In The Apostolic Preaching and Its Developments he traced how the church moved from expecting an immediate end toward this deeper sense of a salvation already present.

Cover of The Apostolic Preaching and Its Developments by C.H. Dodd, Kindle edition

See how the idea grew

In The Apostolic Preaching and Its Developments, Dodd shows how the first Christians' expectation of an immediate end developed into the realized hope of Paul and John. The appendix, "Eschatology and History", sets out his thinking directly.

Get it on Kindle

The debate and Dodd's legacy

Critics replied that Dodd had to explain away too much. The Gospels contain many sayings about a future coming of the Son of Man and a final judgement, and Jesus taught his followers to pray "your kingdom come". The German scholar Joachim Jeremias, while building on Dodd's approach to the parables, proposed instead an eschatology "in the process of realization", and Oscar Cullmann and George Eldon Ladd developed the "already and not yet" framework.

Dodd himself later softened his position and acknowledged a future dimension he had underplayed. Yet his core insight has lasted: almost all scholars now agree that Jesus presented God's kingdom as in some real sense present in his own words and works. Philosophers and theologians still discuss the idea today.

Frequently asked questions

What is realized eschatology in simple terms?

It is the view that the "end times" Jesus spoke about are not only in the future: in his life, death and resurrection, God's kingdom has already arrived.

Who coined the term realized eschatology?

C.H. Dodd, in The Parables of the Kingdom (1935).

Did Dodd believe in the second coming?

Dodd emphasised what had already happened in Jesus, and he treated much of the New Testament's future language as the church's way of expressing hope. He did not deny a final fulfilment, but he placed the decisive event in the past, in Jesus' ministry.

What is the difference between realized and inaugurated eschatology?

Realized eschatology stresses that the kingdom has fully arrived in Jesus. Inaugurated eschatology says it has begun in Jesus but is not yet complete, the "already and not yet" view held by most scholars today.

Sources and further reading

  • C.H. Dodd, The Parables of the Kingdom (London: Nisbet, 1935).
  • C.H. Dodd, The Apostolic Preaching and Its Developments (London: Hodder & Stoughton, 1936).
  • Albert Schweitzer, The Quest of the Historical Jesus (English translation, 1910).
  • Joachim Jeremias, The Parables of Jesus (English translation, 1954).
  • George Eldon Ladd, The Presence of the Future (1974).
  • Mikel Burley, "Dislocating the Eschaton? Appraising Realized Eschatology", Sophia 56.3 (2017): 435–452.

Keep reading